After a family is found massacred inside their Santa Claus, Georgia home, the hunt for their killer hinges on the eyewitness testimony of the three young surviving daughters.
Aired: December 21, 2019
A couple is found murdered inside their home on Christmas morning. All that's left behind is a single palm print. Investigators work tirelessly to match the print to a suspect, until a letter from prison takes the case on an unexpected course.
Aired: December 14, 2019
Just after Christmas, a young couple is found murdered inside their Florida home. Neighbors can't imagine the couple had been in the area long enough to make a mortal enemy. Police uncover deeply personal details, and soon expose a deadly secret.
Aired: December 7, 2019
A mother is brutally shot to death while driving her sons home from a Thanksgiving celebration. When the hunt for her killer leads to an unlikely suspect, investigators soon realize her murder is not as random as it once seemed.
Bloody New Years
Aired: December 23, 2018
Just before New Years, a hockey mom is gunned down at her front door. Later that night, seven more bodies are found in another suburban home. Police discover a shocking connection between the two crimes as they track down the killer.
Silent Night, Lethal Night
Aired: December 16, 2018
When a mother and her two daughters fail to show up for Christmas dinner, officers enter their home and discover all three have been shot to death. The search for their killer reveals an unthinkable family nightmare.
A farmer and his wife in Bacon County were awakened by a dog barking — three young girls in nightgowns stood outside his home. They had survived Jerry Heidler's massacre at the Daniels family home.
The small rural community of ranchers and farmers in Locust Grove was shocked and confused by Jack and Elaine Denney's brutal Christmas Day murder. Rumors about drug users went around, but investigators found nothing to support them.
Prison inmate Justin Walker said he had information on Jack and Elaine Denney's murder. Although he made the unlikely claim that he was hired to do it, he gave information that led authorities to believe he was at least there at the time, former OSBU Agent Vicky Lyons says.
Jack and Elaine Denney touched so many hearts, friend and neighbor Jessica Copeland recalls. No one believed they had really been murdered. And, their funeral was one of the biggest anyone had ever seen.
Grief expert and author of the book “The Journey Through Grief and Loss: Helping Yourself and Your Child When Grief is Shared” Robert Zucker shares insights on getting through the holidays while grieving someone we love.
The scene where Jack and Elaine Denney were murdered looked like a "shootout," former Undersheriff Jason Chennault. No motive could be discerned, and the Christmas Day murders would become a long unsolved Oklahoma mystery.
Reporter Stacey Deffenbaugh recalls how key witness Kellie Ballew stayed out of the spotlight. She was soft-spoken, but well-spoken, she says, and helped prosecutors lay out a timeline of Steven and Michelle Andrews' murders.