Joe and Shawndrea follow up on a handful of "Phoenix sightings,” and begin to question whether she’d been lured into a new life more dangerous than she could have anticipated. A surprising lead takes us to an unexpected locale. 43:54

Phoenix Coldons’ parents are desperate for answers in the 2011 disappearance of their 23-year-old daughter. Her case is turned upside down when investigators uncover evidence of a secret life that may have introduced her to danger. 1:25:52