Oxygen Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View

Charred Remains Identified As Illinois Woman Who’s Been Missing For Nearly A Decade

Bendetta “Beth” Bentley supposedly went missing in 2010 after a mysterious weekend getaway with one of her girlfriends. 

Digital Original
Searching For Nancy Moyer
Oxygen Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View

Searching For Nancy Moyer

On a Friday night in 2009, mother-of-two Nancy Moyer vanished from her home in the small town of Tenino, Washington. In the decade since Nancy went missing, police have investigated numerous credible leads. Could a gruesome murder committed not far from Nancy’s home in 2010 be connected to her disappearance? In July 2019, a man allegedly confessed to Nancy’s murder but then recanted; is he really guilty or innocent? Stephanie Bauer visits Tenino to meet Nancy’s family and try to find answers in this most mysterious case.

State authorities said on Tuesday that they’ve positively identified the body of a missing Illinois woman who vanished during a baffling weekend trek with a friend in 2010. 

The remains, initially discovered in December 2017, were identified as belonging to Bendetta “Beth” Bentley, who disappeared nearly a decade ago, Illinois State Police said in a press release this week.

The remains were “severely burned,” the Northwest Herald reported at the time of the discovery.

On May 23, 2010, Bentley’s friend Jennifer Wyatt dropped her off at a train station in Centralia, Illinois. She was supposedly traveling back to her home in Woodstock. However, she never made it home, and for years, the woman’s disappearance has mystified law enforcement. 

“Information was developed which led the [Illinois State Police] to a rural location in Jefferson County where suspected human remains were recovered at the location,” police said in a press release. 

It's unclear what “information” led detectives to the isolated stretch of Illinois where the woman’s charred remains were discovered. Her body was found near the intersection of Saddle Club and Miller Lake roads in Jefferson County, according to KTVI

Benedetta Beth Bentley Fb

“We’re not releasing any information,” a spokesperson for the Illinois State Police told Oxygen.com on Wednesday. 

“It’s exciting, it’s long overdue,” Bambi Pickard, 59, who co-curates a Facebook page that provides updates on Bentley’s case, told Oxygen.com. She founded the page with a family friend who lived across the street from the Bentleys.  

Pickard, who now lives in Springfield, Missouri, described the woman’s disappearance as having “a lot of twists.”

“It’s something we’ve been waiting for a long time,” she added. “We never gave up hope. We always believed she would be found. I never dreamed it would be this long, though.”

Pickard said Bentley was a “friendly,” “generous,” and “giving” person, who would “do anything to help out a stranger.”

She expects the discovery will bring some closure to the family after all these years. 

“It’s been very hard on them,” Pickard said. “I’m very hopeful that this will bring some justice for the family, and the friends, and all the people who have worked hard to keep Beth out there in the public eye."

Bentley’s husband requested a judge to officially declare his wife dead in December 2017, the Northwest Herald reported. 

“We’re trying to be as normal as possible,” the woman’s husband, Scott Bentley, told the Northwest Herald following his wife’s disappearance. 

“Life doesn’t stop,” he added. “We’ve got bills to pay, you’ve got to do your homework, go to school… You have to just do those things. We’ve been able to make it through.”

The case has flummoxed the woman’s family and authorities, who believe the missing woman lied to her husband about her whereabouts the weekend she vanished, the Chicago Tribune reported.

Bentley’s husband described his wife’s disappearance as “strange” and bizarre” in an interview with the Northwest Herald. 

“That’s why we all think that, unfortunately, that she didn’t leave voluntarily,” Scott Bentley said. “She has three children, including one young one that’s 10,” he added. “And first of all, if you have no money, no credit cards that are being used, no phone, it just doesn’t seem that you would miss birthdays, graduations, sporting events, Christmas. I just don’t think that you would disappear like that.”

Her husband was under the impression that Bentley was visiting Wisconsin with Jenn Wyatt, her friend and co-worker. However, the pair instead traveled to Mount Vernon, Illinois where they relaxed at a lake with Wyatt's boyfriend, the newspaper reported.

Wyatt, who supposedly dropped Bentley off at an Illinois Amtrak station before she went missing, was previously questioned by police, who at times have doubted her story, according to the Northwest Herald. 

“They told me not to say anything right now,” Wyatt told the Northwest Herald when the newspaper contacted her in 2017.

Pickard, the Missouri woman advocating for justice for Bentley, dismissed Wyatt’s account as a “totally made up story.”

There are currently no official suspects in Bentley’s death. She was 41 at the time of her disappearance.

Calling All True Crime Fans
Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more!
Sign Up for Free

Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. Sign up for Oxygen Insider for all the best true crime content. 

You May Also Like...
Recommended by Zergnet