Oxygen Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View

Man Allegedly Shot Wrong Woman To Death In Cabin While Trying To Murder His Ex-Girlfriend

Cameron Jay Moser allegedly shot horse expert Bethany Anne Bernatsky to death inside of a cabin after mistaking her for his former girlfriend.

Bethany Bernatsky Cameron Moser Fb Pd

A Minnesota man allegedly shot a woman to death at a camping resort last week after possibly mistaking her for his former girlfriend, authorities said.

Police were called from Cozy Bay Resort on Lake Edward in Nisswa on Thursday night after a witness heard several gunshots, a press release from the Crow Wing County Sheriff’s Office stated.

“Deputies and other officers responded and encountered an adult male armed with a rifle and a handgun,” the press release stated. “Deputies negotiated for nearly two hours and eventually convinced the suspect to put his weapons down in a safe location.”

That suspect was identified as 29-year-old Cameron Jay Moser of Brainerd.

After he was taken into custody, deputies searched the premises and found Bethany Anne Bernatsky, 46, dead inside a cabin. She was found with multiple gunshot wounds.

Bernatsky had just moved to Nisswa and bared a resemblance to Moser’s ex-girlfriend, who is the daughter of RV park owner Bret Jevning. His RV park is located directly across the street from the resort; Jevning told the Star-Tribune that Moser had come to the park a week before the shooting.

 "He was angry because we weren't giving him access to my daughter,” he said.

Jevning theorized that Moser was “mistaking [Bernatsky] for my daughter" when she was shot to death.

And Jevning is certainly not alone with that theory. Crow Wing County Sheriff Scott Goddard told the Star-Tribune on Tuesday that they believe that Moser may have wanted to shoot Jevning’s daughter.

Ben Bernatsky, a sibling of the victim, told the outlet that the two women look similar in “body structure, height and hair color.” 

"[Moser] killed the wrong person," Bernatsky said.

Bethany Bernatsky had just moved into the resort a few weeks prior to her death. She had spent more than a decade training and performing with horses and most recently ran a paving company in Vermont. The "horse savant," as her brother described her, had planned to spend the winter in the area.

Moser has been charged with second-degree intentional murder. It's not clear if he has a lawyer to speak on his behalf. He's being held on a $1 million bond.

Related

Crime Time is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. Sign up for Oxygen Insider for all the best true crime content. 

You May Also Like...
Recommended by Zergnet