Like other murder cases that have made headlines in New York City — some of which are covered in the second season of Oxygen's New York Homicide, premiering June 10 — the truth is far more complex than people realize.
Anndrea Caruth was in a good stage of life: She had established an early childhood center in New York, and she had a happy relationship with her fiancé and a baby on the way. Then, the Bronx woman went missing.
Christopher Cooley, a kind-hearted Upper East Side widower, was found dead in his locked apartment. Did his new friend he met while receiving cancer treatment at the hospital have something to do with it?