Cynthia Tomlinson planned on visiting her mom and stepdad the day after Easter. When she, as well as friends, were unable to reach them, a police officer dropped by their home. He found rifle shell casings and their bodies.
As police combed the murder scene, nearby, Holly Celiano's mother called her with terrible news. "Just get up here immediately," she said. What she had found would change the course of the investigation.
Joy and Lindsey Champion seemed to have the perfect life. High school sweethearts, they started their lives together not long after graduation. She loved her work as a schoolteacher. He loved his role in the church. But underneath the happy appearances, the couple held a sad secret...
Though their parents cared for them both equally, Emily and Ryan Champion rarely got along. They were both very bright, but Ryan had none of his sister's ambition — and if there was one thing he couldn't stand, it was for her to get more attention than him.
11 a.m. on a Sunday. Lisa Champion hears gunshots, and then her nephew shows up at her doorstep, calling for help. His wrists are tied with duct tape and he has a gun in his hands. The only thing he'll say is that Lisa needs to call 911.