Experienced Investigators Reopen Carl Gaimari Case

With Bill Stutzman leading the pack, these seasoned investigators believe they can solve the cold case of Carl Gaimari.

Season 3 Episode 9 - Videos

2:18

Preview

Why Did This Have to Happen?

Now Playing

2:47

Preview

Experienced Investigators Reopen Carl Gaimari Case

2:13

Exclusive

Investigators Look Back on the Confusing Details of the Carl Gaimari Case

Trending on Oxygen

0:59

Preview

Your First Look at The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre
1:12

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Jake Wagner's Jailhouse Letter
2:34

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Who Were the Wagners?
1:10

Final Moments

Brittanee Drexel’s Mom Desperate for Clues in Daughter’s Disappearance
0:53

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Angela Wagner's Role in the Tragic Murders
2:00

Buried in the Backyard

Police Talk with Becky Stowe's Boyfriend
0:50

Buried in the Backyard

Becky Stowe's Family Launched a Search Team to Find Her
2:45

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Chris Newcomb Tours the Family House
1:18

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

The Mexican Drug Cartel’s Presence in Pike County
0:59

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Jake Wagner's Disturbing Interest in Sexual Abuse
1:12

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Kenny Rhoden Recalls the Lives of His Beloved Late Relatives
2:35

Sleeping With Death

Investigators Recall Reporting Yolanda Holmes’ Murder to Her Son
1:51

Snapped: Killer Couples

Killer Couples: Nick Godejohn Spent 'Magical' Days With Gypsy Rose Before The Murder
1:05

The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Jake Wagner’s Secretive Home Life
1:22

Final Moments

Bart Whitaker’s Father Fights Against Death Penalty Verdict
1:28

Sleeping With Death

Who Was Yolanda Holmes?
2:05

Sleeping With Death

Did Yolanda Holmes’ Boyfriend Play a Role in Her Death?
2:17

Prosecuting Evil with Kelly Siegler

Mysterious Man Launches Attack on Local Wig Shop

Experienced Investigators Reopen Carl Gaimari Case

Season 3 Episode 9 - Videos

Trending on Oxygen

Your First Look at The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre

Jake Wagner's Jailhouse Letter

Who Were the Wagners?

Brittanee Drexel’s Mom Desperate for Clues in Daughter’s Disappearance

Angela Wagner's Role in the Tragic Murders

Police Talk with Becky Stowe's Boyfriend

Becky Stowe's Family Launched a Search Team to Find Her

Chris Newcomb Tours the Family House

The Mexican Drug Cartel’s Presence in Pike County

Jake Wagner's Disturbing Interest in Sexual Abuse

Kenny Rhoden Recalls the Lives of His Beloved Late Relatives

Investigators Recall Reporting Yolanda Holmes’ Murder to Her Son

Killer Couples: Nick Godejohn Spent 'Magical' Days With Gypsy Rose Before The Murder

Jake Wagner’s Secretive Home Life

Bart Whitaker’s Father Fights Against Death Penalty Verdict

Who Was Yolanda Holmes?

Did Yolanda Holmes’ Boyfriend Play a Role in Her Death?

Mysterious Man Launches Attack on Local Wig Shop