Mystery Of What Happened To A Missing Florida Mom 33 Years Ago Helped Solved By ‘Cold Justice’

Mearl Mackey told law enforcement various conflicting stories about the whereabouts of his wife, Evelyn “Laverne” Mackey.

Preview
What Happened To Laverne Mackey?
oxygen Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View

What Happened To Laverne Mackey?

Thirty-three years after the disappearance of Evelyn ""Laverne"" Mackey, cold case investigators look back into her vanishing. Her daughter, Kelly Carpenter, had continuously been in contact with the sheriff's office over the years to check on their progress. ""This case was a 33-year-old case without a body, and that makes it one of the hardest cases to solve,"" said Hernando County Sheriff's Office Detective Randy Williamson.

“What would you say if I told you your mom wasn’t coming home?” 

That was the question Mearl Mackey asked his stepdaughter, Kelly Carpenter, just a few days after her mother, Evelyn “Laverne” Mackey, vanished from their home in Hernando County, Florida in 1981. 

Mearl initially claimed that Laverne was in Ohio, taking care of her brother’s sick wife. Later, however, he told law enforcement numerous conflicting statements, including that Laverne had instead gone to Tampa, that she returned home and became involved with a boyfriend, and that she got into missionary work. 

“Mearl had more stories than Grimms Brothers at this point,” Hernando County Sheriff’s Office Detective George Loydgren told “Criminal Confessions,” airing Saturdays at 6/5c on Oxygen

Confused and afraid, Carpenter asked Mearl to take her to her biological father’s house, and for the next year, investigators attempted to track down answers in Laverne’s disappearance.  

Laverne Mackey

Detectives learned that on the day she went missing, money had been withdrawn from her banking account multiple times. Months later, the account was completely empty.  

But while investigators believed “Mearl wasn’t telling everything” he knew about his wife’s vanishing and that something was “wrong,” there was “no physical evidence” or “sense of any crime scene,” said Det. Loydgren. 

At that point, the case went cold, and it was not until Sergeant Phil Lankin attended the National Homicide Conference 33 years later that an inquiry into Laverne’s disappearance was reignited. During the seminar, Sgt. Lankin pitched the case to former prosecutor and “Cold Justice” host Kelly Siegler, who agreed to reinvestigate with the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office. 

Siegler and the rest of the “Cold Justice” team interviewed multiple witnesses, which further established their belief that Laverne did not simply pick up and abandon her family. 

“After 33 years, we believe that only [Mearl] can explain Laverne’s disappearance,” Detective Randy Williamson told “Criminal Confessions.” 

Laverne And Mearl Mackey

Investigators tracked down Mearl in Chandler, Texas, and executed a ruse: They told him a plane crashed in South America and that they might have found Laverne’s remains, possibly entitling him to money from the airline. In order for Mearl to collect the payment, however, they said he needed to go over his statement regarding her disappearance. 

Mearl agreed, and once back at the station, investigators asked him to authenticate his previous interview transcripts. While he initially claimed that he could not remember what happened the day his wife vanished, Mearl slowly began to validate his prior statements. 

Det. Williamson then confronted Mearl, telling him, “Back then, you told so many different versions of what happened to her … Bottom line, we want to know where she’s at.” 

Mearl continued to claim he had no idea where Laverne — or her body — was located, maintaining he was “not gonna confess.”  

“When this story finally gets told, you’re gonna look like such a flippin’ animal. Such a flippin’ low life,” Det. Williamson said. “Give me the damn body. Because without the body, it looks like first-degree murder in every way, shape, form, or fashion. It’s the absolute truth, and then you add the coverup to it afterwards.” 

After being challenged with the possibility of a first-degree murder charge, Mearl told investigators that he and Laverne went fishing in Inglis, Florida, and that she “fell at the dock” and hit her head. He claimed Laverne was not breathing and bleeding “pretty bad,” and that he then tied an anchor to her body and “watched her sink.” 

“It’s never gone away … It was an accident … I took the anchor. I put it on her. I wrapped it around her with the rope, and I turned her loose and shoved her underneath the dock,” Mearl said. 

When asked where they could find the body, Mearl said he would drive up to Florida and show detectives to the dock, but that he would not allow them to escort him. He then ended the interview and left the room, telling investigators he was “done.” 

Mearl Mackey

Although Mearl had confessed to killing his wife, the case was out of the detectives’ jurisdiction, meaning they had no authority or arrest powers. 

They presented the case to Florida’s Eighth Judicial Circuit Assistant Attorney Brian Kramer, and a grand jury indicted Mearl for first-degree murder. Detectives searched the docks where he claimed to have left Laverne’s body, but they “came to the conclusion there was no way her body was going to be found,” if it was even hidden there at all. 

"Unfortunately, I don’t know that he’ll ever say the location of her body,” Det. Williamson said. 

Mearl pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and was sentenced to 10 years in prison.  

“I believe that Mearl Mackey killed Laverne just for the money in her bank account. He could care less about her being a person, a human being,” Det. Loydgren said. 

To learn more about the case, watch “Criminal Confessions” on Oxygen

Related Stories
Related Show

Crime Time is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. Sign up for our Crime Time Newsletter and subscribe to our true crime podcast Martinis & Murder for all the best true crime content. 

You May Also Like...
Recommended by Zergnet