
PreviewPolice Begin Investigation for James “Jimmy” Sheaffer
"It was like Jimmy fell off the face of the earth."
Season 1 Episode 5 - Videos

Exclusive
Police Remember Angela Stoldt’s Home: “There Was Stuff Everywhere”

Exclusive
Angela Stoldt’s Daughter Reveals Intriguing Information About Their Garage

Exclusive
How Does a Reenactment Help in Police Interviews?

Preview
Investigators Believed Angela Stoldt Was “Definitely Lying”

Preview
Police Begin Investigation for James “Jimmy” Sheaffer