Preview Police Respond to the Scene of Jay Hinton's Murder Oxygen Insider Exclusive! Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! Sign Up for Free to View Police Respond to the Scene of Jay Hinton's Murder Like the John Roberts crime scene, there was evidence of a struggle. Hinton was also found gagged. Watch the Full Episode
1:51 Snapped: Killer Couples Killer Couples: Nick Godejohn Spent 'Magical' Days With Gypsy Rose Before The Murder
2:36 Snapped: Killer Couples Killer Couples: Gypsy Rose & Nick Godejohn Bonus: Nick Godejohn Looks For Redemption In Prison
2:19 The Piketon Family Murders The Piketon Family Murders Bonus: Piketon Murders Were A Conversation Starter