Preview How Deborah Dudley Was Killed In Pit By Gary Heidnik Oxygen Insider Exclusive! Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! Sign Up for Free to View How Deborah Dudley Was Killed In Pit By Gary Heidnik Gary Heidnik wanted to punish Deborah Dudley, so he filled the pit with water — and forced Josefina Rivera to torture the other girls. Watch the Full Episode
