Margo Dilemon, a realtor, went to meet a prospective client — but was never seen alive again. Her disappearance led detectives on a hunt filled with shocking twists and turns.

Roman Stangherlin, a Catholic priest-turned-Florida real estate agent, disappeared in 1982 after his own wife masterminded his murder.

Florida college student Amy Blount went missing after walking away from her crush during a late-night fight.

Denise Huber vanished after driving home at night from a concert in California — and it would take years for police to find her body stored at the home of a disturbing killer.

Leroy Dennis allegedly told his children the bones they were playing with belonged to a possum, but they actually belonged to their mother, who’d gone missing around Christmastime.

Kenneth Cross was 80 years old when he had a fatal run-in with a man who’d already been convicted of violent crimes.

Christopher Denoyer's family received a telegram from "Chris" saying he had run away to live in Los Angeles — but the teen boy was in the house the whole time.

Shannon DePaul’s disappearance in 2017 revealed a disturbing plot among those she knew and trusted.

Peggy Carothers was only 15 years old when she was beaten and buried alive in the Indiana woods — and the culprit was someone close to her.

After Kristin Huggins failed to show up to her first job in the winter of 1992, police were tasked with finding a killer.