S2/EP6 Detective Sergeant Robert Floberg from the Pierce County Sheriff's Office reflects on the murder of Paul Gruber, who was gunned down by handyman Darryl Kuehl at Gruber's home near Muskrat Lake, Idaho. In the six to seven weeks following the murder, Kuehl drained Gruber's financial accounts and began impersonating him. In 1995, Paul's body was found wrapped in a plastic air mattress and buried him four feet under his house.

S2/EP6 Detective Sergeant Robert Floberg from the Pierce County Sheriff's Office recalls how Darryl Kuehl impersonated murder victim Paul Gruber. Gruber was gunned down by handyman Kuehl in 1994 at Gruber's home near Muskrat Lake, Idaho. In the six to seven weeks following the murder, Kuehl drained Gruber's financial accounts and began impersonating him by forging his signature in various documents. In 1995, Paul's body was found wrapped in a plastic air mattress and buried him four feet under his house.

S2/EP6 Shellie Gruber Kepley remembers growing up with her mother and father, Paul Gruber, who was shot at least three times at his home near Muskrat Lake, Idaho. Handyman Darryl Kuehl was found guilty of murdering Paul in 1997. After gunning him down, Kuehl wrapped Paul's body in a plastic air mattress and buried him four feet under his house.

S2/EP6 After Shellie Gruber Kepley does not hear from her father Paul Gruber for an entire month, authorities from Sandpoint, Idaho, break into his home and make a baffling discovery. The home has been completely cleared out of his personal items, including clothing, his computer, and furniture. Larger items such as cars and boats were also missing from his home.

S2/EP6 In 1994, Paul Gruber goes missing from his home in Muskrat Lake, Idaho. His daughter, Shellie Gruber Kepley, grows worried when she does not hear from her father on Valentine's Day or her son's birthday. Shellie's 3-year-old then calls Paul and leaves a message, but they never hear back. A week later, Shellie receives a birthday card for her son from her father, but the handwriting does not match Paul's script.

Buried in the Backyard Bonus: Remembering Carrie Ann Jopek (Season 2, Episode 5)
Carol Tousignant, the mother of Carrie Ann Jopek, remembers what her daughter was like growing up. The 13-year-old went missing in 1982 from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and on September 2, 1983, a contractor found her remains buried under a porch.

Buried in the Backyard Bonus: Jose E. Ferreira Jr.'s Interview with Police (Season 2, Episode 5)
In a 2015 interview with police, Jose E. Ferreira Jr. describes visiting the gravesite of 13-year-old Carrie Ann Jopek, who disappeared from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in 1982. Ferreira tells police how he buried her body under the backyard porch of a nearby house and later returned to the grave, where he cried and apologized.

Buried in the Backyard Bonus: Community Remembers Carrie Ann Jopek's Murder (Season 2, Episode 5)
Members from Milwaukee law enforcement and media group remembe the case of Carrie Ann Jopek, who went missing in 1982 when she was 13 years old. Eighteen months after her disappearance, a contractor found her remains buried under a backyard porch.

S2/EP5 In a 2015 interview with police, Jose E. Ferreira Jr. describes visiting the gravesite of 13-year-old Carrie Ann Jopek, who disappeared from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in 1982. Ferreira tells police how he buried her body under the backyard porch of a nearby house and later returned to the grave, where he cried and apologized.

S2/EP5 Carol Tousignant, the mother of Carrie Ann Jopek, remembers what her daughter was like growing up. The 13-year-old went missing in 1982 from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and on September 2, 1983, a contractor found her remains buried under a porch.

S2/EP5 Members from Milwaukee law enforcement and media group remembe the case of Carrie Ann Jopek, who went missing in 1982 when she was 13 years old. Eighteen months after her disappearance, a contractor found her remains buried under a backyard porch.

S2/EP5 In a 2015 interview with police, Jose E. Ferreira Jr. describes visiting the gravesite of 13-year-old Carrie Ann Jopek, who disappeared from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in 1982. Ferreira tells police how he buried her body under the backyard porch of a nearby house and later returned to the grave, where he cried and apologized.

S2/EP5 Carol Tousignant, the mother of Carrie Ann Jopek, remembers what her daughter was like growing up. The 13-year-old went missing in 1982 from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and on September 2, 1983, a contractor found her remains buried under a porch.

S2/EP4 Vance Tibbetts, the brother of Jerilyn Towers, remembers what it was like searching for his missing sister, who disappeared in1982 from the Gateway Lounge in Newport, Maine. When police later searched for her buried body in 2000, Tibbetts believed her remains would not be found.

S2/EP4 Vance Tibbetts, the brother of Jerilyn Towers, remembers what it was like searching for his missing sister, who disappeared in 1982 from the Gateway Lounge in Newport, Maine. When police later searched for her buried body in 2000, Tibbetts believed her remains would not be found.

S2/EP4 Maine State Police remember investigating the disappearance of Jerilyn Towers, who vanished in 1982 from the Gateway Lounge in Newport, Maine. Towers' boyfriend, Smith, had recently broken up with her via a letter, which Towers had with her the night she went missing.

S2/EP4 In 1982, Jerilyn Towers, a 34-year-old mother of three, disappears from Newport, Maine, after spending the evening at the Gateway Lounge, a local bar and pizza pub. Her brother Vance Tibbetts recalls receiving a call from his mother the following morning, who said Jerilyn had not contacted her or returned home.

S2/EP4 On October 11, 2000, law enforcement officers in Etna, Maine, dig up the backyard of a ramshackle house. Resident Vance Tibbetts remembers when investigators located human remains and how he believed it could be the body of his missing sister, Jerilyn Towers, who disappeared from Newport, Maine, in 1982.