Blackened, gutted, and tipped on its side, Charli's car is discovered about 10 miles from Kimbelyn's home. Kimberlyn immediately fears the worst. "It just felt like things went black around me," she says.

After meeting a new man, 19-year-old Demetria Hill goes missing. Her mother, Sharon Williams, won't stop searching.

Kimberlyn Scott and her daughter, Phaedra, had hoped to find Charli at her house. But the front door is locked when they get there — and when Phaedra climbs in through the window, Charli seems to have been gone for a long time.

Demarco remembers the "glowing aura" that seemed to surround his mother. "You would want to be her friend," he says. But when Demarco was just three years old, his mother's life was cut tragically short.

Stressed out about how much time has already passed, Kimberlyn insists on talking with Steven and having him write down every detail of his last night with her daughter. But when she meets with him, he's frustratingly nonchalant.

John Smith’s brother told jurors he wanted to call the police when he found the hacked-up body of John’s ex-wife, Janice Hartman — but his grandfather punched him in the face at the idea of betraying a family member.

While Kimberly is picking out a shirt for her date, Joe sneaks up from behind and begins strangling her. She fights him off, then runs and grabs a curling iron. She wraps the cord around her wrists and swings at him until he leaves

Joseph Brown, a convicted felon, was the last person to see Demetria Hill before her burned, hacked-up body was found in the woods behind an Atlanta church. 

At a hearing over a protective order, Daniel Drill-Mellum smirked and licked his lips, Abby Honold says. It re-traumatized her and helped spark the will in her to fight back.

According to Abby Honold, Daniel Drill-Mellum persuaded her to follow him back to his apartment to help get more alcohol for game day at the University of Minnesota in 2014.

Sentencing day was difficult, and the courtroom was packed with supporters of the women, as well as supporters of Daniel Drill-Mellum. Abby Honold says she shook and cried as she gave her victim impact statement.

Abby was afraid to smile for photos that would go on social media, believing they might be used by Daniel's defense team to undermine her case. She also found it hard to function as a student.

Abby Honold expected to get a call with information about Daniel Drill-Mellum's bail amount. Instead, she learned that he was being released.